Dan Patrick Shouldn’t Let a Sports Emmy Decide His Future

"The best move Patrick can make is to take the pledge off the table. Whether he stays or goes shouldn't hinge on whether an awards committee decides his show is worthy of a trophy."

Date:

Dan Patrick is one of the most respected sports talk radio hosts of all time. Many, including myself, would put him on the Mount Rushmore of those who have ever commanded an audience. He built an independent platform and became the first proof of concept for a generation of broadcasters to follow. He’s also currently slated to walk away from his program on February 11, 2028, in Atlanta during Super Bowl LXII media week.

In the words of the great Lee Corso, “Not so fast, my friend.” The catchphrase is particularly ironic, especially considering Patrick’s team of Paul Pabst and Andrew Perloff now hosts a show that shares the same slogan on Peacock.

- Advertisement -

Last week, Patrick made a statement that shook the industry. He said he would extend his run on The Dan Patrick Show by a full year if the program were to win a Sports Emmy in 2027. That means instead of walking away as scheduled, as he has promoted and led audiences to believe for years since signing his most recent extension in July 2023, Patrick would push his departure date to February 9, 2029, in Las Vegas.

Unfortunately, that statement puts everyone involved in an unusual situation. It’s one that doesn’t have a true winner on any side.

The Sports Emmy has been an elusive award for The Dan Patrick Show. While Patrick owns one himself for his work with ESPN in 1997, his daily program has missed out six separate times as a nominee. Last year, the show didn’t even make the cut.

Winning a Sports Emmy isn’t easy. Neither is earning a nomination. But Patrick has now put himself and his radio program in a difficult position. By saying he will stay another year if The Dan Patrick Show wins a Sports Emmy, he’s also putting pressure on the National Academy of Television Arts & Sciences.

The Argument

Consider this.

If The Dan Patrick Show wins the Sports Emmy, Patrick stays for another year. But the award could become less about the work itself and more about whether Patrick follows through on his retirement plans. Fair or not, there will be an asterisk within the industry and, potentially, in Patrick’s own mind.

Did the show win because it was the best daily studio show of the year? Or did voters simply want another year of Dan Patrick on the air?

Patrick would likely agree that every show in that category competes based on its body of work. If The Dan Patrick Show earns a nomination, however, its entry into the competition will come with a public storyline tied to the outcome. As a result, the playing field tilts. Even if no voter on the committee would ever admit it.

The other way to look at this is to consider what happens if The Dan Patrick Show loses for a seventh time. Patrick already introduced that possibility when he made his statement last week.

“There might be people who want me out of the business. So maybe there’s a reason why we won’t win,” Patrick said.

That line changes everything. Why?

Because it puts an unfair burden on those responsible for determining the Sports Emmy winner. It’s also an unfair way to frame a loss. That’s the trap in Patrick’s statement. Win, and the award looks coerced. Lose, and the Academy looks like it showed a legend in the industry the door.

There’s also a human cost that’s easy to miss. Patrick’s staff has lived with an end date for years. Now, part of their timeline hinges on a vote they can’t control. That’s a lot to hang on a trophy.

That’s why there’s no winner in this situation, from Patrick and his staff to the people within the Academy responsible for nominating the shows and choosing the winner.

The obvious pushback is that Dan Patrick is kidding. To be fair, he did slightly undercut his own promise almost immediately after making the statement. But words matter, and no one knows that better than Patrick himself. They carry weight, create pressure on the committee and leave an audience waiting to see how everything unfolds.

The Best Move

Patrick has never wanted anything handed to him throughout his career. He’s earned everything he’s accomplished while building The Dan Patrick Show. Has Patrick wrestled with his decision to retire since making it? Of course, and most of us would do the same. Walking away from something you built is never easy.

But Dan Patrick has spent nearly two decades building something that can’t be measured by a trophy, a nomination or a vote from an awards committee. He’s built a daily destination, earned the respect of his peers, developed a loyal audience and created a program that has become one of the most recognizable brands in sports media.

That’s a legacy worth celebrating on its own merits. Neither Patrick nor his show needs a Sports Emmy to validate his accomplishments. The people who have listened, watched and worked alongside him don’t need one to understand his impact, either.

If Dan Patrick wants to continue working beyond February 2028, that’s his decision to make. And I would be among the first to welcome it. He’s earned that right.

But the best move Patrick can make is to take the pledge off the table. Whether he stays or goes shouldn’t hinge on whether an awards committee decides his show is worthy of a trophy. He should make that decision separately. Then he should let the show stand on its own when nominations come out next year. If it wins, everyone will know it was earned.

That’s the Emmy Dan Patrick deserves. It’s the one without strings attached.

Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.

- Advertisement -
John Mamola
John Mamolahttps://linktr.ee/johnmamola
John Mamola is Barrett Media's sports editor and daily sports columnist. He brings over two decades of experience (Chicago, Tampa/St Petersburg) in the broadcast industry with expertise in brand management, sales, promotions, producing, imaging, hosting, talent coaching, talent development, web development, social media strategy and design, video production, creative writing, partnership building, communication/networking with a long track record of growth and success. He is a five-time recognized top 20 program director in a major market via Barrett Medi's Top 20 series and has been honored internally multiple times as station/brand of the year (Tampa, FL) and employee of the month (Tampa, FL) by iHeartMedia. Connect with John by email at John@BarrettMedia.com.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Triton DigitalTriton DigitalTriton Digital

Next Article