Mike Florio believes ESPN should look at Peyton and Eli Manning to replace Troy Aikman. The Pro Football Talk founder says fading interest in the ManningCast should factor into that decision.
What We Know: The ManningCast has shed much of its audience since peaking in 2021 where the program regularly topped over a million viewers per episode. In Week 7, it drew just 517,000 viewers on ESPN2 for Cowboys-Eagles. Meanwhile, Aikman’s five-year contract, reportedly worth $90 million, expires after this season. Additionally, Aikman has acknowledged he will become a free agent, while Joe Buck signed a reported $108 million extension. In an appearance on The Dan Patrick Show, Florio argues that the declining viewership should serve as an opportunity for ESPN to think about Peyton and possibly Eli Manning as Aikman’s replacements.
What They Said: (All quotes via The Dan Patrick Show):
Mike Florio believes the declining interest in the ManningCast should factor into ESPN looking at Peyton and Eli Manning to replace Troy Aikman: “Nobody watches the ManningCast. Let’s be real about it. It’s a vanity thing. Hey, maybe we’ll win an Emmy, whatever the case may be. The numbers keep going down. Who wants to watch a podcast with a football game in the background? I want to watch the game. It doesn’t bring in one additional viewer to the game. So why not just take Peyton Manning from that environment and put him in a booth? Bring Eli [Manning] too and let’s do a three-man booth again.”
Mike Florio thinks ESPN will sign someone who will make less than Troy Aikman: “I think they believe they’ll be able to find someone who will be happy to take that job for a lot less than whatever Troy Aikman wanted. If he truly was trying to get 30 million a year, even if that’s the opener, that’s the kind of thing that can cause the negotiations to go sideways quickly.”
What Remains Unclear: ESPN has not committed to re-signing Aikman. However, Florio believes money is the sticking point. ESPN President Jimmy Pitaro spoke on the issue Tuesday saying that he fully expects both Buck and Aikman to remain professional through the Super Bowl LXI broadcast in February. It’s unknown who ESPN will target as Aikman’s potential replacement.
What It Means: Ultimately, ESPN faces its biggest booth decision since landing Buck and Aikman in 2022. A Manning booth would put its most famous partners in front of its largest audience. However, that move would likely end the ManningCast as fans know it. Either way, the clock starts ticking after Super Bowl LXI.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.


