Years ago, I was pretty vocal about my belief that local social media influencers could become the next generation of radio personalities.
It made sense to me. These were people who had already figured out how to build an audience, develop a distinctive voice, and generate consistent engagement. They understood their communities and knew how to make people stop scrolling long enough to pay attention.
Those sound like qualities radio should want.
I still believe social media is a tremendous place to discover talent. But I have also learned that success on social media does not always translate into success behind a radio microphone.
The recent changes at BBC Radio 1 have brought that conversation back. The station is adding personalities with strong digital and social media backgrounds as part of a broader schedule shake-up. It raises a question that music radio companies everywhere should be asking.
The Influencer vs. Radio Debate
Should we take influencers and teach them how to become radio stars? Or should we take radio personalities and teach them how to become influencers?
I am not sure the answer is one or the other.
Just because someone has a million followers does not mean that person can do a great radio show. Creating an entertaining 60-second video is different from creating a compelling three- or four-hour program. Both can be recorded, edited, and refined. In today’s voice-tracked music-radio environment, air talent may have several opportunities to get a break right.
But radio still requires a different kind of discipline.
A personality has to create continuity across an entire show, understand the station’s music and audience, deliver information economically, and make each appearance feel connected to the one before it. A strong social post can succeed as one isolated moment. However, a strong radio personality has to create a relationship one break at a time, day after day.
Why Follower Counts Aren’t Enough
Radio also requires a form of intimacy that is difficult to measure through follower counts. A creator may reach millions of people through individual pieces of content, but can that person make one listener feel like they are part of an ongoing conversation? Can they create familiarity, consistency, and a reason to return tomorrow?
Some creators can. Others simply do not translate.
Traditional radio personalities should not use that as a reason to dismiss them.
The people succeeding on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube understand several things radio talent desperately needs to learn. They understand how to identify an audience, speak its language, respond to feedback, and create content people actively seek out.
They also understand that content creation is not something done only when there is time left over. It is the job.
What Radio Talent Must Learn
Successful creators do not wait for a manager to hand them an assignment or tell them what to post. Instead, they study what connects, experiment with ideas, respond to their audience, and keep creating. They know that consistently producing content is how they build currency.
That is where radio talent must stop living inside the radio bubble.
Being active on social media cannot be something personalities do because corporate sent another memo or because their boss included it in a performance review. They should be building their presence because it increases their value as entertainers, influencers, brand representatives, and potential endorsers.
More importantly, it creates value for themselves.
The Case for Building Your Own Audience
Call letters can change. Formats can disappear. Companies can restructure. Therefore, a personality who has built a genuine relationship with an audience has something that can move with them.
The microphone may introduce a personality to an audience, but social media gives that relationship somewhere to continue. It allows talent to extend stories, respond to listeners, reveal more of their personality, and reach people who may never have heard the original radio segment.
That does not mean every radio break needs to become a video. It does not mean personalities should spend the entire show thinking about what might perform well on TikTok. Radio still has to serve the audience listening in the moment.
But the content should not always end when the microphone turns off.
Finding the Right Balance
Radio companies should continue looking at social creators as potential talent. But follower counts should be the beginning of the evaluation, not the end. Creators still need coaching, show structure, and an understanding of what makes radio different.
At the same time, experienced broadcasters cannot reject social media as promotional busywork and expect their careers to remain secure.
The future probably does not belong exclusively to radio people or social media influencers. Rather, it belongs to personalities who can do both — people who can command the microphone, understand the music, and create a daily relationship with an audience while also knowing how to make that content travel beyond the station.
The question is not which group wins.
The question is which group is willing to learn the other half of the job.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.
David Hill serves as a Music Radio Editor, Columnist and Features writer for Barrett Media. A radio lifer with more than 30 years behind the mic, in the control room, and in the program director’s chair, David’s career spans influential stops at brands such as WIYY 98 Rock, WBAL-AM, and 99X. He has worked across multiple formats and ownership groups, including iHeartMedia and Cumulus Media, developing talent, breaking music, and navigating every major industry shift from diary to PPM and terrestrial dominance to streaming disruption. When he’s not writing or analyzing the industry, Dave runs The Tune Farm, a marketing firm built to help artists and brands grow audience the same way great radio always has—by creating connection, not just impressions. He can be reached at David@BarrettMedia.com.