Full disclosure: I am not a pumpkin spice latte guy. Aside from a slice of pumpkin pie on Thanksgiving, you will rarely catch me ordering a sugary pumpkin drink at a drive-through. Instead, if I’m going to lean into pumpkin during autumn, give me a craft-brewed pumpkin ale paired with a hearty Irish beef stew. That is a proper fall pairing.
Whether you love the flavor or roll your eyes at the annual invasion, you have to respect brands that take something predictable and turn it into brilliant creative storytelling.
Creative Campaigns That Capture Attention
Consider what Dunkin’ just rolled out on social media. On one end of the spectrum, they brought back actual Spice Girls Emma Bunton and Geri Halliwell Horner for a Hollywood-level mockumentary. Rachel Dratch played “Pumpkin Spice,” a long-lost sixth bandmate who left pop stardom to make lattes.
On the other end, they posted an absurd, low-fi reel featuring a mascot named “Spidey D.” He swung through a store parking lot to save the fall flavor launch. Rather than playing it safe with polished product shots, Dunkin’ leaned straight into chaotic internet humor. This sparked a viral comment section filled with all-caps boomer jokes (“THIS IS NICE HONEY… FELL AND HURT MY BACK”) and fans cheering on “Unc wilding in the Dunkin parking lot.”
Ultimately, they prove a compelling lesson: whether you have a massive production budget or just a costume in a parking lot, embracing self-aware, unhinged creativity builds immediate connection. This is exactly where local media can learn a massive lesson.
Real Spice Versus Artificial Syrup
If you examine the raw science behind real pumpkin spice, ingredients like cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves are packed with actual health benefits. In small doses, they improve focus, soothe digestion, and give your brain a genuine mood boost.
Therefore, authentic seasonal radio should do the same. When we lean into autumn with real creativity, we deliver warmth and community connection:
Natural Antioxidants: Authentic local stories, hometown high school football rivalries, and community drives serve as fuel for listener loyalty.
The Focus Boost: Tying show topics to changing fall routines gives your station an immediate, timely energy boost that keeps listeners locked in.
Avoiding the Sugar Crash and Listener Fatigue
The problem with pumpkin spice season is rarely the spice itself. It’s the artificial syrup, heavy cream, and excessive sugar that get dumped into the recipe.
In radio, we fall into that exact same trap when we get lazy with seasonal programming:
Empty Calories: Drowning your show in generic Halloween trivia or reading off basic community calendar items gives your audience zero substance. It is pure artificial filler. Anyone can do it.
Digestive Disruption: Hammering the exact same three autumn promos on repeat creates instant listener fatigue. However, three is better than one, unless we’re talking about drinking three sugary lattes before noon.
Encouraging Big, Bold Swings Behind the Mic
Dunkin’ won the season because they were willing to attack fall from two totally different creative angles. They did not settle for the easy, safe option; they took big, absurd swings and fully committed to the bit.
Autumn gives local radio a natural tailwind. Nonetheless, we have to bring real imagination to the table:
High Production or Low Fi, Just Commit: You don’t need a million-dollar budget to make an impact. Whether you build an elaborate benchmark feature or run a hilarious, low-budget parking lot stunt like Spidey D, total commitment to the joke is what makes it work.
Build a Community Comment Section: Notice how Dunkin’s absurd posts get people typing in all caps and sharing with family members. When your on-air content is genuinely funny and relatable, listeners don’t just listen silently. They call, text, and share it with everyone they know.
Find Your Own Craft Brew: Just because everyone else is selling lattes doesn’t mean you have to copy them. Find the unique angle. Discover the unexpected pairing. Identify the local community twist that fits your specific brand and audience.
Balance Flavor with Substance: Pair your playful fall promotions with real local impact, like coat drives, food pantry blitzes, or honoring local first responders.
Do Not Settle for Ordinary
Your listeners are craving warmth, humor, and connection this time of year. Do better than slapping artificial pumpkin flavoring on a lazy broadcast and calling it a day.
Take a cue from a craft brewer, a fake nineties pop star, or Spidey D in a parking lot. Bring real craft, bold humor, and genuine substance to your stations. Make this fall unforgettable for your audience.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.
