AI Lawsuits Bring Payola Questions to Streaming

"This time, the laundry is coming out of streaming. And it’s coming out through lawsuits."

Date:

The rumors swirled about how it all went down. Maybe it was a poolside bar in Miami. Maybe it was somewhere else entirely. Nobody’s quite sure which version of the story is true. What’s for sure is that the payola scandal rocked the entire music industry.

What’s happening now isn’t exactly the same thing. But as most of us already know, the music industry has plenty of dirty laundry — hidden secrets nobody wants exposed. This is a tale of another set of them.

- Advertisement -

We’ve Seen This Movie Before

In the mid-2000s, New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer went after the major labels for pay-for-play. Sony BMG settled first, paying $10 million in July 2005. Warner followed with $5 million that November. Universal paid $12 million in 2006.

That was real money. But the emails did the real damage. Spitzer put them out for everyone to read, and they showed trips, electronics, contest cash, and independent promoters working as the pipeline between label budgets and station playlists. The FCC followed with its own crackdown on the big radio groups.

The fines mattered. What changed the business, though, was everyone finally seeing what was really deciding the music on the air.

What’s in the Hamper Now

This time, the laundry is coming out of streaming. And it’s coming out through lawsuits.

According to a new Digital Music News report, Universal and Sony are locked in court with AI music company Suno, and Sony is also fighting Udio. Warner licensed both and walked away. Now the cases have reached discovery, which is where the secrets live.

Suno wants Apple to testify about its deals with Universal and Sony. That includes alleged “anti-AI” terms limiting what Apple Music can recommend, plus guaranteed royalty minimums Apple pays no matter what people actually stream. Apple is fighting it, and a hearing is set for Dec. 1.

Let me get this straight. The labels are suing the AI company. The AI company is subpoenaing the streaming service to dig up dirt on the labels. And the streaming service is trying to get out of the room before anybody asks what’s in its contracts. I need a flow chart just to keep up with who’s accusing who.

Suno and Udio also want label-by-label stream data from the Mechanical Licensing Collective, covering every major DSP back to 2021. Pandora and Apple have told the MLC to keep that data locked up.

Meanwhile, the labels want DistroKid to say how many AI tracks it has pushed onto streaming services and what those tracks earned. Think of DistroKid as the modern indie promoter — the middleman whose records tell the story.

Even Suno’s investors are getting subpoenas. One former venture capital principal is being deposed over a post saying he’d moved most of his listening from Spotify to Suno.

In 2005, the question was who was paying to get a song on the air. In 2026, it’s who’s paying, or pressuring, to get a song into your feed.

Where the Comparison Breaks

Let’s be fair. This isn’t a carbon copy.

No government is involved this time. These are private lawsuits, and protective orders could keep most of this sealed. The roles are flipped, too. In 2005, the labels were writing the checks. Now they’re the plaintiffs, and the payola-style accusation is Suno’s defense: that the majors use their catalogs as leverage to control what streaming services surface. And at its core, the case is about AI training on copyrighted music, not bribery.

Still, nobody needs to hand a programmer a laptop anymore. A contract clause telling a platform what it can recommend does the same job — with better lawyers.

Who Picks the Hits?

Here’s the part radio people should hold onto. Radio survived payola, and the reforms arguably made it better.

Streaming has spent the last decade selling itself as the neutral alternative to “bought” radio. Just you and the algorithm. If these filings show the algorithm comes with terms and conditions, that story changes.

That’s an opening for radio. Human curation by people listeners know and trust isn’t a relic. It’s a feature.

Honestly, maybe we skip the courtroom altogether. Put the label heads, the Suno and Udio founders, Apple, the MLC, and DistroKid on one big couch. Let Andy Cohen run it like a Bravo reunion special. The Real Housewives of the Music Industry would out-rate anything on streaming.

Courtroom or couch, it’s still dirty laundry.

The laundry is coming out either way. This time, nobody needed a subpoena from Albany. The industry is serving the subpoenas on itself.

Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.

- Advertisement -
David Hill
David Hillhttps://barrettmedia.com
David Hill serves as a Music Radio Editor, Columnist and Features writer for Barrett Media. A radio lifer with more than 30 years behind the mic, in the control room, and in the program director’s chair, David's career spans influential stops at brands such as WIYY 98 Rock, WBAL-AM, and 99X. He has worked across multiple formats and ownership groups, including iHeartMedia and Cumulus Media, developing talent, breaking music, and navigating every major industry shift from diary to PPM and terrestrial dominance to streaming disruption. When he’s not writing or analyzing the industry, Dave runs The Tune Farm, a marketing firm built to help artists and brands grow audience the same way great radio always has—by creating connection, not just impressions. He can be reached at David@BarrettMedia.com.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Triton DigitalTriton DigitalTriton Digital

Next Article