How Mary Walter Became One of the Top Fill-In News/Talk Radio Hosts

“If you’re available on short notice all the time, if you’re really good and low maintenance, they’d rather have you there for that because it’s easier for them than finding a full-time host.”

Date:

With the holidays around the corner, there is one major need for every station: finding a good fill-in host. So we asked one of the best in the business, Mary Walter, how she gets the desired gigs in the highly competitive market, what she does during the slower seasons for fill-in hosts, and how AI could affect the future of fill-ins.

“You’re always fighting the tide,” acknowledged Walters, who has been a fill-in host for a variety of outlets, like SiriusXM and Fox News Radio for 20 years. “There’s always the flavor of the week that’s coming up, right? Someone who has very little radio experience, but is a really great podcast host, or someone who’s just a really great guest, and they’ll give them a shot because they’re the new flavor. [So there is a lot of competition.”

- Advertisement -

Standing Out as a Fill-In

Walter always stands out by being true to herself and not trying to impersonate the host she is filling in for. She also makes herself available to not only host, but she is known to book, write, and clip the show she’s filling in for.

Walter does forewarn that doing this, as a fill-in host who is looking for a full-time gig, might not always be the best option. “I had been filling in on a radio station for years, 10 years, and I had filled in for pretty much every day part, every host. They’re like, ‘Oh, you’re our favorite fill-in,’” she said.

The station was known to have a revolving door of hosts. So when she asked a producer why they kept passing her up for a full-time gig, the producer told her, “This is going off the record: you’re too reliable.”

“They know it’s harder to get a fill-in who can be there on short notice, does a really good job, and is low maintenance and easy to work with than it is to get someone who’s full-time,” she said.

It was the moment Walter recognized the “pitfall” of her incredible capabilities. “If you’re available on short notice all the time, if you’re really good and low maintenance, they’d rather have you there for that because it’s easier for them than finding a full-time host.”

Life During the Slow Season

Putting that frustration aside, another holiday season came and went, and the slow season for fill-in hosting began. Typically, Walter turns to voiceover work. “I do get some voiceovers, but with AI, a lot of that is dying down, unfortunately,” she said with dismay.

According to Walter, the one area where AI still can’t handle voiceover work is the medical field, because “a machine doesn’t necessarily know the pronunciation of certain medical terms.”

With voiceover work drying up, she has turned to TV during the slow fill-in hosting season. “I’m a Newsmax contributor, so that keeps me busy,” she affirmed. “I do hits mostly from home. Some days I do go into the city, and I’ll be what they call a super guest, and I will do four to eight hits in a day.”

Why AI Won’t Replace TV Guests Anytime Soon

More importantly, Walter feels AI won’t be able to take over her TV gig anytime soon. “I think it’s hard for TV to [replace guests with AI] because a lot of what we do is political commentary.”

“So you’re going to pay an AI person that’s really just programmed by someone else to give commentary or an opinion on politics or whatever it happens to be. That’s kind of hard. Maybe we’ll get there, but you know, everybody knows that that person isn’t really that person. There’s a nameless person behind that. And does that become a risk to a station because AI can say things that aren’t real, and the question becomes who is liable? I think there’s a lot of questions with it.”

Keeping Your Name Out There

Regardless of how AI develops, there are two other things Walter is doing to not only keep the AI dogs at bay but also stand out from the crowded field of fill-in hosting. “If you’ve already been on radio, you have a name, and people know your name. You should get a podcast to keep your name out there. Promote the heck out of your podcast to keep your name out there. And you need to network, network, network.”

By networking, she means going to events like the Barrett Media Audio Summit. “Get business cards made up. The more people see you and get to talk to you and get to know you, the more gigs you’re going to get.”

Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.

- Advertisement -
Krystina Alarcon Carroll
Krystina Alarcon Carroll
Krystina Alarcon Carroll contributes features and columns for Barrett Media. She has experience in almost every facet of the industry including: digital and print news; live, streamed, and syndicated TV; documentary and film productions. Her prior employers have included NY1 and Fox News Digital and the Law & Crime Network. You can find Krystina on X (formerly twitter) @KrystinaAlaCarr.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Triton DigitalTriton DigitalTriton DigitalTriton Digital

Next Article