CBS News made headlines again this month, and 60 Minutes sits right in the middle of it. Bari Weiss added four new correspondents to the program’s roster, and the mix says a lot about where she wants to take the broadcast. Ross Douthat, Sebastian Junger, Gianna Toboni and Trevor Phillips make up the new class, and only two of them come from a traditional TV reporting background.
That imbalance is the story here, in my opinion. Toboni and Phillips have logged real time in front of cameras, chasing stories and building the instincts that live and taped broadcast work demands.
Douthat and Junger haven’t. Douthat spent his career at The New York Times writing opinion columns. He has said openly that he feels awkward on camera. Junger built his name as an author, best known for The Perfect Storm.
None of that makes them bad hires on its own. But it does raise a fair question: can a writer become a broadcaster just because someone decides they should?
A Tough Ask, Wrapped in Good Intentions
Weiss hired an executive producer without TV experience. Now she’s leaning on writers and podcasters to carry one of the most storied names in broadcast journalism. That’s not necessarily a mistake — but it’s a leap.
Mitch Hedberg had a great bit about this exact tension, comparing it to a cook who worked hard to master the kitchen, only to get asked if he can also farm. The skills don’t always transfer, no matter how good someone is in their original lane.
Douthat is a sharp writer and a rigorous thinker. Junger has produced work that shaped how a generation understood war and disaster.
Neither fact guarantees either man can carry a 60 Minutes segment the way past correspondents once did. Broadcast storytelling asks for a different set of instincts — pacing, presence, the ability to draw a subject out on camera rather than on the page. Those instincts are built through repetition, not talent alone.
Still, I want to be careful here. And fair.
Unorthodox Isn’t the Same as Ill-Fated
Unorthodox and ill-fated aren’t interchangeable, even though people often treat them that way. Ill-fated is only applied in hindsight, after a decision has already gone wrong. Unorthodox just means a choice breaks from the norm, and plenty of unorthodox choices in media history have paid off. Weiss might be onto something. Toboni and Phillips give the new class real reporting depth, and their presence suggests Weiss isn’t abandoning broadcast fundamentals entirely.
Even so, legacy programs carry more risk than most. 60 Minutes begins Season 59 with its brand resting on a very specific kind of credibility. Viewers expect polish, precision and a correspondent who can hold a room without ever losing control of it. Asking four newcomers, two without any broadcast background, to hit that mark right away is a significant bet.
Weiss clearly wants to reshape the program, and that’s fair — it’s her job. CBS News hired her to make exactly these kinds of calls. My concern isn’t the ambition. It’s the assumption that talent in one medium automatically carries over to another. Sometimes it does. Sometimes it doesn’t. Audiences notice the difference fast.
The next several months will tell us a lot. Every new segment featuring Douthat, Junger, Toboni, or Phillips will get measured against the correspondents who came before them, fairly or not. That scrutiny isn’t going away, and neither is the pressure it puts on Weiss’s early tenure at CBS News.
I don’t know yet whether these hires will look smart a year from now. Nobody does. But I do know the magnifying glass is already out, and 60 Minutes rarely gets a quiet season to figure things out. Weiss’s CBS News tenure may end up defined by how this particular gamble plays out, for better or worse.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.
Garrett Searight is Barrett Media’s News Editor, which includes writing daily news stories, features, and opinion columns. He joined Barrett Media in 2022 after a decade leading several radio brands in several formats, as well as a 5-year stint working in local television. In addition to his work with Barrett Media, he is a radio and TV play-by-play broadcaster. Reach out to him at Garrett@BarrettMedia.com.