Nexstar Media Group reportedly faced tough questioning from federal appeals judges over restrictions on its $6.2 billion acquisition of local television station owner Tegna. Although the deal has closed, a court order prevents the two broadcasters from integrating operations.
What We Know: A three-judge Ninth Circuit panel heard arguments Tuesday in Pasadena, California, over the court’s restrictions. According to reports by Deadline and Courthouse News Service, judges questioned Nexstar’s proposal to narrow the order. DirecTV and attorneys general from 13 states sued in March, citing reduced competition and higher television costs. The acquisition would give Nexstar stations reaching approximately 80% of U.S. television households. Moreover, Nexstar wants restrictions limited to approximately 31 markets where both broadcasters own stations, arguing the order exceeds the alleged competitive harm. However, judges questioned whether those stations could realistically operate separately. Meanwhile, DirecTV and the states argued that broader restrictions are necessary to preserve competition. Opponents also raised concerns about newsroom consolidation, job losses and reduced local news coverage. Nexstar maintains the merger would benefit consumers. The panel issued no ruling, with a jury trial scheduled for July 2027.
What They Said: “In this broadcast merger context, it’s very common to hold separate stations. Across Democratic and Republican administrations, the federal DOJ has challenged mergers making very similar claims to the ones that plaintiffs make here.” — Deanne Maynard, attorney for Nexstar Media Group
What Remains Unclear: The appeals court has not established a timeline for deciding whether to ease the restrictions on Nexstar and Tegna. It remains uncertain whether the existing order will stay in place, be narrowed or undergo further review. Meanwhile, the broader antitrust lawsuit remains unresolved, leaving questions about when the companies could fully combine their operations.
What It Means: The legal battle creates further uncertainty for one of the largest acquisitions in local television. For Nexstar, the restrictions delay efforts to combine operations and realize anticipated cost savings. Meanwhile, DirecTV and the states argue that the merger could reduce competition, increase television costs and weaken local news coverage. The case also highlights broader concerns about consolidation within the broadcasting industry. Its outcome could influence how future television station mergers are reviewed and challenged under antitrust law.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.


