Fox News just posted a number that has plenty of people sounding the alarm. In October, the network averaged 1.7 million primetime viewers, down 28% from last year. That’s the largest year-over-year drop in the month before an election in the past decade.
Naturally, the hot takes followed. Many observers see a blue wave on the horizon, and they point to unfavorable feelings toward Republicans. President Trump’s low approval ratings, they say, only deepen the slump.
I don’t buy it. The real explanation is simpler, and it has less to do with any party’s popularity than with how exhausted Americans are.
This Isn’t the First Dip
Fox News has seen midterm-season drops before. In October 2020, the network averaged 2.2 million primetime viewers. That year was hectic, but it was also a presidential election. In 2022, the figure fell to 1.5 million. It rebounded to 1.6 million ahead of the 2024 presidential election.
Here’s the part the doom-mongers skip, though. This October’s 1.7 million actually beats the 2022 number. Percentages look scary when the starting point is high, but the raw audience still sits in familiar territory. So the slump is real, but it’s hardly unprecedented.
The Real Culprit: Political Fatigue
I’ll say this, and I believe it to my core: the issue is much more about political fatigue than any one party’s unpopularity.
The 2026 cycle will feature the most political advertising ever, with more than $11 billion spent. That didn’t start six weeks ago, either. Political messages have bombarded Americans for months.
Consider my own week. Twice, the only items in my mailbox were political ads. I also watch a lot of YouTube. How many ad breaks did I sit through during roughly two hours of content on Monday night that didn’t include a political ad? Zero.
The ads are inescapable. Billboards, radio, podcasts, TV, YouTube, digital and direct mail all carry them. One candidate’s a crook, the other’s a sleazeball, and the country’s going to hell in a handbasket.
Ratings Aren’t Ballots
Remember, too, that ratings measure who’s watching television, not who’s voting. Plenty of people tune out cable news and still show up at the polls. Others watch every night and never cast a ballot.
Viewership is a shaky way to forecast anything about turnout.
Meanwhile, if unpopularity drove the drop, you’d expect the slide to last longer than a single month. Instead, we’ve got one October number and a lot of speculation.
One Month Doesn’t Make a Trend
So wouldn’t it be logical to think people are plum tired of it all? Why would they seek out even more political content by tuning in to Fox News? That makes sense to me, and it should make sense to you.
Of course, I’m not saying ratings never matter. If February arrives and Fox News still sees 28% declines, concern is warranted. Until then, one month doesn’t make a trend.
People are tired, man. And oftentimes, the most likely answer is the correct one.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.
