I spent the weekend poking around Kansas City with my son, and Saturday night we landed at Morton Amphitheater for Five Finger Death Punch. It’s the band’s 20th anniversary tour, so expectations were exactly what you’d think: loud, heavy and unapologetic.
But before Five Finger Death Punch assaulted the stage, Cody Jinks walked out.
Jinks is a country artist — a platinum-certified outlaw country artist, but country nonetheless. On paper, he’s an odd fit for a hard-rock crowd. He gets very little major-market country airplay and has virtually no path onto rock radio. Bring this pairing up in a music meeting, and it probably never makes it out of the room.
It didn’t need to. It worked — 100%.
Not expected, but welcomed. And knowing the rebellious nature of bands like Five Finger Death Punch, it made perfect sense. This isn’t the first time a headliner has reached across genre lines for an opener, and it won’t be the last. But it’s worth asking why live music keeps pulling this off while radio rarely tries.
It Wasn’t About Format. It Was About Attitude.
The pairing wasn’t built on format. It was built on attitude.
Both acts appeal to people who value independence, authenticity and defiance. Both deliver music that doesn’t sound overly polished or manufactured. Five Finger Death Punch has plenty of chart success. Jinks, on the other hand, has built his career largely without the country charts. His music rarely racks up big airplay numbers, but it thrives in person, with an active, loyal core that shows up. The crowd didn’t care where Jinks ranks on a chart. They cared that he meant it.
Cody Jinks walked onto a hard-rock stage as an apparent mismatch and walked off proving that the audience’s musical boundaries may be far wider than radio’s.
That’s the part programmers should sit with. Listeners don’t organize their lives by format. We do. They organize their lives by who they are, what they believe and what makes them feel something.
Radio Has Gotten Very Good at Protecting Itself
Radio has become so disciplined about protecting its formats that it may also be protecting itself from surprise.
I understand why. For years, programmers have been trained to eliminate anything that might cause someone to change the station. I was one of them. Research, clocks, rotations and tight playlists exist for good reasons, and they’ve helped build some great brands.
But in stamping out every possible tune-out, we may have also eliminated some of the moments that make people love a station. The song you didn’t expect. The artist you didn’t know you needed. The “wait, what was that?” moment that sends someone to their phone to look it up.
Those moments build loyalty. And they’re hard to come by in a format that never steps outside its own lines.
A Little More Rebellion, Please
Radio doesn’t need to abandon research or randomly throw unfamiliar songs into rotation. That’s not the lesson here.
A handful of people have already tested this idea under the “rebel country” banner, blending outlaw country, Southern rock and country into one sound. JVC Broadcasting flipped a Panama City Beach station to Rebel Radio 100.1, billed as “Country Music with Grit,” with Southern rock mixed into the library. Pandora built a station called Rebels Hard Rock Country — and Five Finger Death Punch is one of its rock mainstays.
Did any of it work? I’m not sure, and I’m sure people will argue it on either side. But the experiment — the concept — is what really matters here. It’s not necessarily about dedicating an entire format to the idea. It’s about giving yourself permission to break the bounds of what listeners expect to hear coming out of the radio speaker.
In plenty of other formats, that’s called an “oh wow” moment. Here, it’s just called rebellious.
The lesson is that the audience will follow you further than you think — as long as the connection is real. A rock station and an outlaw country artist share more DNA than any format grid would suggest. The same could be true for plenty of other stations and the artists sitting just outside their lane.
So try the unexpected song. Build a feature around an artist from just outside the format. Create a concert pairing that shouldn’t work. Give listeners an opportunity to surprise us.
Some of it won’t land. That’s fine. Some of it will, and when it does, it becomes the kind of thing people are still talking about on the walk back to the parking lot.
Maybe radio doesn’t need to become Cody Jinks. But it could stand to borrow a little of his rebelliousness, take an occasional chance and stop assuming that everything unexpected is automatically wrong.
Sometimes the odd fit fits perfectly.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.
