I worked for iHeartMedia in Indianapolis for about 32 seconds. In that short stretch, one thing stood out. Years of radio layoffs had stripped the building lean. It was a machine built to keep things on the road. Empty chairs. Empty studios. Ghosts of the past.
I thought that would change when I moved to Kansas City and joined Cumulus. Granted, it was the middle of the pandemic. But once again, the empty chairs and dark studios felt like relics of an industry gone by. And here’s the thing about an empty chair. You can take a salary off the books in an afternoon. Replacing the relationship that person built with your audience takes considerably longer.
The Math Isn’t Working
That’s been on my mind since Barrett Media reported last week that Cumulus has started another round of layoffs hitting on-air personalities in several major markets. It comes just weeks after the company emerged from Chapter 11 in October. It’s also the second round this year, following cuts in August.
I read Barrett Media every day, and I write for it. So I have to face the cold reality that layoffs will keep happening. Sometimes the math just doesn’t work. Right now, it isn’t working. But that leaves every manager with a harder question than “What can we cut?” How do you calculate the value of what you’re removing?
What Walks Out the Door
A familiar personality does more than fill breaks. They’re the morning habit that brings listeners back. They’re the voice that makes a local advertiser’s endorsement believable. They know the charity directors, the venue owners, and the community leaders. And they know the market well enough to make a show feel like it belongs to its town.
Skid Roadie was a legend here in Kansas City, a true musicologist. People knew who he was, and he knew who they were. When Skid decided to retire, I hired Sparks for afternoons at KCFX. So hiring still happens. Sparks was the new kid on the block, and he’s done a great job of ingraining himself into the brand and the station. But that kind of connection takes time. Skid had built it over years. Sparks had to earn his own.
I think everybody agrees local is a more powerful tool than syndication. To be fair, some syndicated shows do a pretty damn good job of replicating the market, and we’ve written about that here. But sounding local and being local aren’t the same thing.
Three Questions Before the Cut
None of this means longevity protects a job. Revenue pressure is real, and every position has to earn its keep. But has management measured the person’s full contribution? Or did it just find an expense that’s easy to eliminate? And what’s the plan to hold on to the audience and the advertisers that person brought with them?
What do listeners lose tomorrow morning? Not in theory. What actually changes when they turn on the radio?
What revenue does this person influence? Count the endorsements, appearances, sponsorships, and clients who stay because of a relationship.
What replaces their contribution? Name who, or what, delivers it now.
If you can’t answer those, you don’t have a staffing decision. You have a budget cut without a product plan.
What’s Still Worth Buying
Technology is going to take us places. AI is going to take us places. But without somebody sitting in that chair, where are we really going? Local wins. Syndication is probably on the rise. And a little piece of magic gets sucked out of radio every time another studio goes dark.
So ask yourself why people choose us. Do they want to talk to a guy somewhere else, or a guy around the corner? There isn’t one right answer for every station. But I know my tendencies. I want to talk to my neighbor first.
The people who keep investing in talent are the ones who will win eventually. So before you eliminate a position, finish this sentence: Listeners will keep choosing us because _____. Your answer needs to be as clear as the savings.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.


