The Sequel Arrives: Telos Alliance Releases Voltair II for Radio Broadcasters

If you need just one minute in a quarter hour to gain credit, a new Voltair unit may be overkill. That said, if a listener tunes in for, say, two or three minutes, especially in spoken word with a host who doesn’t encode well, it could make a difference.

Date:

Hollywood knows that sequels are good business. If a movie is successful and lends itself to future stories, there is a built-in audience for the next one. The same is true for a radio story, that of Voltair from Telos Alliance. The sequel is here. Voltair II is now available.

If your time in the radio business is short or you’ve only worked in diary markets, let me explain Voltair. It’s a system that increases the “volume” of the Nielsen PPM watermark code. I’ve written about PPM encoding in the past, but let’s review briefly.

- Advertisement -

PPM has multiple layers, and the code for radio stations resides on layer 1. A full code should take about 4.5 seconds and includes information such as the station ID and a date/time stamp. The key is that listeners can’t hear it; in other words, the code is subaudible. It “hides” behind the program material. The PPM watch, and before that the “pager size” meter, pick up that code and save it. Typically, the meter downloads data to Nielsen once a day.

How Voltair Works

For music stations, this should work well because the enemy of PPM encoding is dead air. It’s also the enemy of music stations. However, other formats have gaps, especially spoken-word formats. Further, some broadcasters will tell you that certain voices work better with PPM than others.

In the 2010s, Telos developed Voltair, which was designed to increase the strength of the PPM code at the station level. Install it in your chain, and you could even watch how the codes were doing, right there on your PC!

Guess what? It worked! Early adopters saw their ratings improve, which forced competitors to buy the box for their stations. Eventually, most competitive stations had Voltair units and enjoyed a year of improved estimates until post-Voltair data was compared with post-Voltair data. I was at Cumulus when the company started adding the original Voltair units because, frankly, it did what Telos said it would do.

From Golden Ears to Silver Ears

When Arbitron developed PPM, a great deal of testing was done, including using “golden ears” (with apologies to Golden Earring and David Bowie’s “Golden Years”).

If memory serves, some of the testing was done using classical music on the BBC. Classical has more pauses, and the BBC’s lack of compression would make the code stand out to the testers. If they couldn’t hear the PPM codes under the music, that would be the right level of code.

What Voltair did was reduce “golden ears” to “silver ears.” A Voltair box could crank up the PPM code, but too much push would drive listeners away, as the code artifacts would be audible on the air. Finding the right amount of “boost” would improve your ratings without alienating any listeners.

What’s New in Voltair II

A decade later, the sequel has arrived. I had a chat with Marty Sacks, Telos’ EVP of Strategic Partnerships, to find out what’s new. Marty said three things drove Telos to develop Voltair II:

  • Parts were no longer available for the original Voltair units. If one broke down, there might be issues in getting it fixed.
  • A broadcaster had concerns that some of their voices were not encoding well, even with the original Voltair units in place.
  • A watermarking analyzer was added to the actual Voltair unit, resulting in a “closed loop” design. It became easier to see what was working, allowing users to “set it and forget it.” In other words, the new unit can determine the proper level of encoding boost.

The new version is a “pin for pin” replacement for the old one. Take the old unit out and put the new one in.

Will Voltair II Make a Difference?

Telos doesn’t have access to Nielsen data, but Marty says the feedback from testing in multiple major markets is that the ratings improvement is on the order of 2-5%. While Telos has been informed about gains with Voltair II, I’m a little skeptical this time.

When Voltair was first introduced, PPM was handled the same way as the diary service, meaning five minutes won the clock quarter hour. Then Nielsen moved PPM credit to three minutes, and we are likely to see a one-minute quarter hour very soon. It’s already used in local TV. If you need just one minute in a quarter hour to gain credit, a new Voltair unit may be overkill. That said, if a listener tunes in for, say, two or three minutes, especially in spoken word with a host who doesn’t encode well, it could make a difference.

However, if we peer into the future, it’s possible that Nielsen could move to average minute, much as it has been used in national TV for years. Numeris in Canada has used average minute for radio in PPM markets from the beginning. Average minute means every minute counts, which would make Voltair II an extremely important part of your audio chain.

Gaming the System

Is using a Voltair (original or II) gaming the system? Perhaps, but we’ve been gaming the system since Sarnoff and Paley in the 1920s. Digital does it. If you read my column about YouTube’s new measure of “impressions,” your only response can be that they’re gaming the system. Spectrum defaults your video to their news channel whether you wanted to watch it or not. A century after the first radio broadcasts, nothing has changed.

Let’s meet again next week.

- Advertisement -
Dr. Ed Cohen
Dr. Ed Cohen
One of the radio industry’s most respected researchers, Dr. Ed Cohen writes a weekly business column, heavily focused on ratings research for Barrett Media. His career experiences include serving as VP of Ratings and Research at Cumulus Media, occupying the role of VP of Measurement Innovation at Nielsen Audio, and its predecessor Arbitron. While with Arbitron, Cohen spent five years as the company's President of Research Policy and Communication, and eight years as VP of Domestic Radio Research. Dr. Ed has also held the title of Vice President of Research for iHeartMedia/Clear Channel, and held research positions for the National Association of Broadcasters and Birch/Scarborough Research. He is adjunct faculty in the Department of Broadcast Communications at Western Kentucky University and welcomes your thoughts. Reach him by email at doctoredresearch@gmail.com.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Triton DigitalTriton DigitalTriton Digital

Next Article