Former WIP host Angelo Cataldi is not softening his stance on SportsRadio 94 WIP, instead amplifying his criticism following a pointed response from current afternoon host Spike Eskin.
During an appearance on The National Football Show w/Dan Sileo, Cataldi dismissed the reaction to his original comments, framing the situation as overblown while sarcastically leaning into the generational divide that has fueled the exchange.
“Oh my god, stop the presses. Two old guys got together and started talking about how much better they did their jobs than these young whipper snappers that are working today,” said Cataldi. “Give me a friggin break would you please?”
However, Cataldi’s tone sharpened when addressing Eskin directly. After Eskin labeled his comments “disappointing and embarrassing” and touted current ratings success at WIP. Cataldi pushed back on both the substance and the framing of that response.
“I’ve been communicating with Howard [Eskin] since our conversation. The conversation was not designed to create any sort of an issue,” explained Cataldi. “I said to him, ‘Why don’t you tell your son, Spike, and all the other people over there that they can take a bow for how amazing they are now…’ Come back to me in another 30 years, and then tell me how great your numbers are, or how you’re lapping people.”
Cataldi also contended that stations today maintain closer relationships with the teams they cover, which he believes impacts the tone of on-air criticism. According to Cataldi, that shift represents a departure from a journalism-based approach that prioritized accountability over access.
“I don’t care if they’re upset,” Cataldi said, emphasizing that his comments were consistent with how he approached the job throughout his career. “In the case of WIP, You represent the Phillies and the Eagles. As long as they’re happy, you’re happy. That’s a problem. That’s not my generation of doing sports talk. My generation was at least rooted in journalism, which is rooted in accountability.”
Beyond the personal back-and-forth, Cataldi broadened his critique to include the current direction of WIP’s programming. He argued that the station now operates with a different agenda, one he characterized as being more focused on maintaining positive relationships than challenging teams in a way that reflects fan frustration.
“They’re insecure because they have a different agenda now,” said Cataldi. “They’re trying to please different people. They are really interested in pleasing the teams they talk about, which is a dumb agenda. It’s dumb.”
Cataldi said his perspective reflects what Philadelphia listeners have historically expected. He described a style built on confrontation, passion, and direct accountability. Cataldi argued that reducing those elements weakens the connection between host and audience. He said that remains true regardless of ratings or platform expansion.
“If you’re a fan of a team and you’re frustrated, that’s what you want to hear. That’s what you want to see, and they don’t do it anymore,” said Cataldi. “That’s why they’re not doing that great a job anymore. Anywhere, not just WIP, all the sports media in Philadelphia. There are a bunch of p***ies. Put that in your headline. There are a bunch of p***ies.”
While the language he used underscored the emotion behind his stance, the central message remained consistent with his earlier remarks: Cataldi believes the format has drifted away from its roots.
“I don’t care if they’re [WIP] upset. It never bothered me that they’re upset. Howard [Eskin] asked me an honest question. I gave an honest answer. I’ve done that my whole life,” said Cataldi. “I’m not gonna change it now because I’m worried that Spike Eskin is gonna and get all skitzy and in his own head. Oh no, he’s saying mean things.”
The debate highlights a familiar tension in sports radio between legacy voices who built the format and current hosts navigating a rapidly evolving media environment, with WIP once again at the center of that conversation.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.
