The Super Bowl Halftime Show is entertainment. It’s unique to the sport and the league. A championship determined through a single game rather than a seven-game series. MLB, the NHL, and the NBA wish they had the opportunity to replicate it. This year’s selection for the Super Bowl Halftime Show is Latin pop sensation Bad Bunny.
The 31-year-old Puerto Rico native is a three-time Grammy Award-winning global artist and one of the most streamed musicians on the planet. With more than 100 billion streams across platforms and 80.5 million monthly listeners on Spotify, the NFL’s decision makes perfect sense. The league has been clear about its intent to reach younger and more global audiences — and Bad Bunny delivers both.
Still, since the announcement, backlash has been building. Some of it comes from political criticism. Some from personal taste. But now, there’s a growing conversation about whether someone — or something — could actually counterprogram the Super Bowl Halftime Show.. The question is, can it be done—and how?
Every year, the Super Bowl dominates American television. Nineteen of the 20 most-watched broadcasts in U.S. history are Super Bowls. The last three games alone sit atop that list.
Halftime Is A Hit
Last year’s game wasn’t just another big number — it was the most-watched broadcast ever. The halftime show drew 133.5 million viewers as Kendrick Lamar performed a set filled with Compton pride and subtle jabs at Drake. The internet lit up with memes of Lamar pacing the 50-yard line, smiling as he delivered his message.
That’s exactly what the NFL wants — a halftime show that grabs attention, trends globally, and gets people talking long after the game. And Bad Bunny has already done that without performing a single note.
In 2019, the NFL signed an agreement with Roc Nation, which is owned by rapper Jay-Z. As part of the deal, Jay-Z was named live music entertainment strategist in charge of producing the halftime show and aiding the NFL with social justice initiatives. This deal was signed following the controversy surrounding Colin Kaepernick kneeling during the national anthem in protest of police brutality and racial inequality.
Since then, the Super Bowl Halftime Show has featured Shakira and Jennifer Lopez, The Weeknd, Dr. Dre, Snoop Dogg, Mary J. Blige, Eminem, Kendrick Lamar, Rihanna, and Usher — with Bad Bunny set for 2026. Notice the pattern? The league has leaned into artists who reflect younger, more diverse audiences rather than the classic rock comfort zone of acts like The Who or Coldplay.
So if that’s the direction, can anyone really steal their thunder?
Who Can Even Attempt
For starters, any media partner of the NFL won’t even try. With this season’s game airing on NBC, you can cross off CBS, ESPN, Amazon Prime, Netflix, FOX, and YouTube immediately. No one wants to jeopardize their relationship with the NFL, the most valuable sports property in the country.
The same goes for digital sports brands. Their traffic, sponsorships, and access all depend on the NFL. Going head-to-head with the league on its biggest day would be professional suicide.
The NFL has too many ties to too many brands for someone to go against the shield on its big day.
That’s why we get the Puppy Bowl annually on Animal Planet, Discovery Channel, TBS, and truTV (all owned by Warner Bros. Discovery), which received an average of 12.8 million viewers last year. That’s a higher viewership number than every game of the MLB postseason so far and the NBA Finals last year.
FOX attempted a counterprogramming measure in 1992, airing a live episode of In Living Color to go head-to-head with Gloria Estefan’s performance as a salute to the 1992 Winter Olympics. FOX began broadcasting the NFL in 1994. The move by FOX to counterprogram has been credited with signaling the NFL to improve its product at halftime of the Super Bowl.
But that was three decades ago — long before streaming, social media, and second screens. Today, trying to chip away at the NFL’s broadcast audience would be a fool’s errand. The smarter move would be digital.
Dominate Digital
The NFL is simply too popular to strike a significant dent in the traditional viewership of the Super Bowl. The halftime show is now designed to cater to younger and more diverse audiences than ever, drawing attention for months leading up to the moment of execution.
The goal shouldn’t be to cut into the viewership of the halftime show—it should be to dominate the conversation online. It’s the same approach advertisers take with their commercials during the broadcast of the game.
Digital currency is the currency to earn if you attempt to counterprogram. If your 25-minute programming can dominate online conversation over the latest Doritos ad or a new movie trailer, that’s where you win. Attempting to draw viewership on traditional television like the Puppy Bowl should not be the goal. The Puppy Bowl has a 20-year head start on you already.
It doesn’t have to be music. It could be comedy, gaming, influencer-driven content — anything that gives audiences an alternative experience, not just another performance. Competing with the NFL on its own terms rarely works; giving people something completely different might.
Can it be done? Yes. Could counterprogramming be considered a success? Certainly.
But it’s a high-risk play. The upside for a brand that tries might not outweigh the cost. The NFL’s reach, resources, and cultural footprint make it nearly impossible to “beat” the halftime show in any traditional sense.
And that’s okay. Sports and music both exist to bring people together, not divide them. The halftime show has never been designed to please everyone — it’s meant to create a shared cultural moment.
So if Bad Bunny’s performance isn’t your thing, there’s an easy solution. No need to rage, protest, or counterprogram.
Just turn the television off.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. To stay updated, sign up for our newsletters and get the latest information delivered straight to your inbox.


