In the crowded landscape of digital content, Reality Check with Ross Coulthart from NewsNation is proving that a fresh approach can cut through the noise.
Since the inception of the YouTube Podcast Charts earlier this year, the show has been in the top 100 each week. Most recently, it outperformed some of the biggest names in the medium — beating out Call Her Daddy, Flagrant, and Mel Robbins. Even more impressively, it topped legacy news giants like 60 Minutes and PBS NewsHour in the most recent rankings. That’s not a one-week fluke. It’s a sign of a program that understands its audience, its niche, and how to deliver on both.
For many, those rankings might come as a surprise. After all, Reality Check is not chasing the traditional podcast formula that blends celebrity gossip and interviews, viral videos on TikTok, or shock humor.
Instead, Coulthart dives into subjects the mainstream press often treats with skepticism or avoids entirely. He has built an audience by covering topics that, as he puts it, “media isn’t supposed to be interested in.” Whether it’s UFOs, government secrecy, or unconventional geopolitical analysis, he’s not afraid to lead with curiosity.
That’s exactly what makes this success so noteworthy. Podcasting is often celebrated for its diversity of voices and formats, but the most visible successes have historically skewed toward certain genres — comedy, self-help, celebrity interviews, and a few elite news brands. Coulthart’s presence near the top of the YouTube charts broadens that picture. It shows that even in a platform environment dominated by entertainment-first content, there’s a significant appetite for deep-dive reporting into topics that seem too unconventional for the evening news.
What makes Reality Check’s chart performance even more interesting is the mix of competitors it’s outpacing. Call Her Daddy isn’t just a podcast — it’s a cultural phenomenon, with massive Spotify deals and nonstop mainstream coverage. Flagrant thrives on unfiltered banter and big-name guests, often pulling millions of views with just a few clips. Mel Robbins’ show rides the wave of the booming motivational podcast market, while 60 Minutes and PBS NewsHour carry decades of journalistic credibility and built-in audiences.
Yet Coulthart’s program, without the same level of corporate promotion or brand saturation, is beating them where it counts — in the latest YouTube rankings.
That tells us two important things about the current podcast environment. First, the YouTube Podcast Charts aren’t simply an echo of legacy media power. They’re reflecting genuine audience engagement in a space where viewers vote with their clicks, not just with name recognition. Second, niche subject matter, when executed with authority and intrigue, can compete with — and sometimes surpass — the biggest names in the business.
Coulthart’s advantage lies in his presentation style. He’s not shouting over his guests, chasing viral one-liners, or relying on gimmicks. Instead, Reality Check delivers a sense of urgency and importance in every episode. He treats even the most unconventional topics with the same seriousness as a high-profile political interview. That builds credibility with his audience and separates the show from the pack.
There’s also a lesson here for anyone producing digital content in 2025: the “safe bet” isn’t always the winning bet. NewsNation could have launched yet another conventional political roundtable or celebrity-driven interview series. Instead, they backed a journalist with a track record of investigative depth and a willingness to explore the stories that other outlets leave on the cutting room floor. That risk is paying off in measurable, public ways.
Of course, no one should pretend the rankings alone make Reality Check the future of news podcasts. YouTube is only one platform, and the dynamics of chart performance can change quickly. But podcast consumers are hungry for something different — and not “different” in the contrarian-for-contrarian’s-sake way that often burns out quickly. They’re looking for hosts who treat them like smart, engaged adults who can handle a topic that doesn’t fit neatly into the day’s partisan narratives.
The fact that Coulthart is winning those viewers while competing against shows with far bigger promotional machines says a lot about the power of trust and consistent delivery. Reality Check may never be as flashy as the top entertainment podcasts, but it doesn’t need to be. Its chart position speaks for itself, and more importantly, it speaks for an audience that values depth over spectacle.
In a medium that thrives on diversity of content, Reality Check with Ross Coulthart is living proof that there’s still room — and an eager audience — for the kind of reporting that challenges, surprises, and informs. The recent rankings aren’t just a win for Coulthart or NewsNation, which needs to create impact in any way that it can.
They’re a reminder that the future of podcasting is as wide-open as the questions he asks every week.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. To stay updated, sign up for our newsletters and get the latest information delivered straight to your inbox.
Garrett Searight is Barrett Media’s News Editor, which includes writing daily news stories, features, and opinion columns. He joined Barrett Media in 2022 after a decade leading several radio brands in several formats, as well as a 5-year stint working in local television. In addition to his work with Barrett Media, he is a radio and TV play-by-play broadcaster. Reach out to him at Garrett@BarrettMedia.com.
