Every Tuesday we speak with a different expert or leader from somewhere in the vast music industry. Label executives, artist managers, programmers, talent, artists, consultants, and beyond. To be considered as a future guest, email me at keithblackboxgroup@gmail.com.

Today we sit down with a veteran from the label and artist side of the music industry: Tyson Haller. He is currently the SVP, Promotion & Artist Strategy at Shelter Music Group, working with a wide range of artists. Including newer acts like Dexter and the Moonrocks and Des Rocs to veterans like Godsmack, Joe Perry, and ZZ Top.

So, let’s dive in.

Today’s Spiderweb

Keith: Artist promotion has become more like navigating a spiderweb than the linear course it once was. How has the daily role of “promotion” changed over the past few years? And what new benchmarks for success are must-hits that weren’t in place just a few years ago?

Tyson: The definition of Promotion has changed for me just from the fact that I am now on the management side of the table. While the traditional sense of the word still holds true, like getting and growing airplay and promoting single and album releases, it has become much more about the artist and less about a release. For one, bands and management make most of their money from ticket sales and merch sold at concerts, so right off the bat, promoting tours is a top priority. And radio is great for that! So giving radio access to the band for interviews, meet and greets, sessions and stuff like that is just as important as when I am working a single up the charts.

It’s just that now, I am trying to put those opportunities together, even when there is no album to promote. It could be from a heritage band that hasn’t had a record in years and doesn’t plan to have one any time soon. Or even more importantly, it could be with a band that doesn’t even have a label, but continues to tour. Artists want to stay relevant and keep a high profile, and continuing to work with radio with or without a new single, helps them do that.

When to Pour on the Gas

Keith: When you’re deciding how hard to push a record, what’s the first sign that tells you to go all-in? What’s a signal that can be misleading and you trust the least?

Tyson: I don’t think that having low streaming numbers necessarily means you don’t have a radio hit. Oppositely, I don’t think that just having millions and millions of streams means that you do have a radio hit. There are tons of songs out there streaming millions that will not work on radio. Obviously, if I see an artist of ours with big streaming numbers, I am going to use that as part of the reason radio should play it, but the song also has to fit the station I am pitching to.

There are other things too that are in play to make a record worth playing. If a band is selling out shows in your market, but streaming is mediocre, it still may be worth playing their music. Same with Shazams. If people are taking the time to buy tickets with their hard earned money or taking out their phone to shazam a song, it means there is a positive reaction to the music in the market.

What Does it Mean to “Make It” Today?

Keith: It used to be simple — release a record, gain a hit or two at radio or MTV, sell records for cash flow, the artist is soon in arenas, and they’ve “made it.” It’s very different today. What’s your definition of “making it” in 2026?

Tyson: I think the level of “making it” differs for every artist, but I would say that if you are able to make a living from purely being a musician, then you’ve made it. That’s a tough hill to climb, and that success doesn’t have to come from just one thing. It can come from streaming, ticket sales, merch, whatever. Of course, some artists consider having #1 records or playing Madison Square Garden as examples of making it. And those are big events too.

But it’s hard making a living as an artist, so if you can do that, then you’re in an exclusive club.  I will say, there are lot of bands out there right now that feel because they get a lot of likes on a few posts that they’ve made it. We’ve managed some bands like that. And I don’t want to discount those accomplishments, because you do definitely want that fan engagement, but sometimes having just success on socials clouds an artist’s judgement, to thinking they don’t need to do any more work than that.

The Artist’s Truth Teller

Keith: In your role, you have to be an artist’s advocate and also a truth teller. Sometimes an artist’s vision just won’t work. How do you navigate changing an artist’s course when their vision isn’t going to add up in the long run?

Tyson: I think the key is acknowledging the artist’s vision first and foremost, and then respectfully giving your professional opinion on the topic. If the artist strongly disagrees, I think sometimes you just need to move forward with their plan, because as management, we do technically work for the artist, but it is crucial to give your thoughts on what the outcome may be if they don’t take the advice.

Partnerships and Marketing

Keith: Artist partnerships with equipment makers or even tour sponsorships have been around forever. Shelter Music Group thrives on creating strategic partnerships that lead to both revenue and marketing. Tell us what a real partnership looks like and give a recent example that delivered results for all parties.

Tyson: Shelter has a great relationship with Danny Wimmer and are fortunate to have a deep presence in a lot of the festivals he puts together like Aftershock, Bourbon & Beyond, Louder Than Life, Sonic Temple and Welcome To Rockville. Music festivals are a big business and the fact that we have so many bands playing those events, it is great exposure in front of a very large audience. And it really helps build credibility and profile for a lot of our developing acts that would have no opportunity to play in front of such a large crowd at that stage in their career if it were not for those festivals. We’re really fortunate in that manner.

The Radio Reality

Keith: I know you’re a believer in radio but also see its challenges. Do you see the overall cultural influence of rock radio growing or shrinking? If you believe it’s shrinking, like some of your colleagues do, how can it get back to growing and becoming more of an influence?

Tyson: I actually think that Rock Radio is in a really good place right now! There are so many iconic rock stations that are winning in their market! A lot of the time beating both the Alternative and the Top 40. Take WMMR in Philly for example. It is consistently Top 5 in the market and sometimes even #1 12+. Same with KISW in Seattle; consistently Top 5 and ahead of the Alternative and the Top 40. There’s no Alt in Baltimore, but WIYY is killing it. WXTB in Tampa, too. It’s not even just Major Markets, WGRD in Grand Rapids is #2 in the market! KLAQ in El Paso, #3!

Listen, I love Alternative Radio as it’s a very important part of breaking new music, and there are some big and very successful Alt stations winning out there, but the #1 record on the Active Rock Chart often times has a bigger audience than the #1 record at Alternative. That wasn’t always the case.  And Rock Radio sells concert tickets! Promoters know that and bands know that!

TikTok or Touring

Keith: I’ve met a lot of younger artists over the past 10 years that aren’t focused on touring at all. They believe the path of focus should be TikTok, IG, and getting on curated playlists. If you’re advising a younger talent, of course you’d want both, but which is more important — emphasis on digital presence or getting out on the road?

Tyson: I’m going to keep this one simple, just to make a point. Touring. You’re not selling out MSG from TikTok.

What’s Harder

Keith: In 2026, what’s harder — breaking a new artist or keeping a decades-old artist relevant, and why?

Tyson: Breaking a new artist is always difficult. There are so many things that need to go right. So often timing and luck are a big part of it. Currently with new artists, a big challenge is breaking through all the noise and beating the algorithm in social media. What is the best content to create and how do we promote that content to attract the most eyeballs? Oh and of course, the song needs to be a smash too or none of it matters.

On the other point, there is a lot of nostalgia right now that is fueling a great deal of renewed interest in older bands. Creed is the most obvious example. But we are also seeing it with Lit, Fuel, Hinder and others! The older generation loves hearing songs from their past, while young kids are simultaneously finding these hits for the first time on social media or DSP’s like they were new. It’s fueling a whole new ticket buyer and building new social media followers all at once.

The Most Challenging Strategy

Keith: No one can expect a one-size-fits-all strategy blueprint for artists. What’s been one of the harder strategies to develop because the artist was so unique? How did it work and play out?

Tyson: We’re going a few years back, but the best example of fitting a square peg into a round whole for me was Macklemore & Ryan Lewis. When “Thrift Shop” came out, it sounded like nothing else on the radio. On the first listen one could have been mistaken to think that the song was just a novelty. But I could see that data firsthand with the insight that they had multiple hit records, in addition to “Thrift Shop,” already reacting in downloads and on YouTube all at the same time.

Since I worked at ADA then, it wasn’t feasible to go straight to Top 40 radio, so we put together a campaign to prove the record first at Alternative. While the local streaming data alone wasn’t always convincing enough for the Alt PD to feel like the record could fit on their station, the strategy was. Based on the big streaming numbers in the market, give us a spin or two and watch the phones, texts and/or Shazam’s light up from YOUR station listeners. It worked every time. The song only went Top 15 at Alt, but that’s only because Pop radio started picking it up. Alt felt they needed to move on to another song to differentiate themselves from the competition. It ended up being a #1 record at Pop, and pretty much the biggest song of the year.

The Tyson Philosophy

Keith: You’ve worked with artists at every stage — breaking, rebuilding, maintaining. If you had to boil down your entire philosophy of developing and breaking artists into one or two sentences, what is it?

Tyson: Write a great song, get great tours and work hard on the road to partner with radio. Add a good content strategy to that, and you’re set up as best you can to have a hit.

The Blank Slate

Keith: Last question. You can say anything you want to any sector of the music industry. What do you want them to hear?

Tyson: I am a big believer in the live aspect of music. It’s one of the remaining shared experiences we have with a group of other people who we may not know personally, but feel a connection with. We’re all in that one space together for one reason and that’s because of our common love for the music.

Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.