Sunday’s Super Bowl preshow performance featuring Green Day and the Halftime Show featuring Bad Bunny had not only the music community talking, but the world itself. Especially across social media.
Yet, despite the expected reactions from both sides of the political aisle there is a larger conversation to be had. That conversation centers on expectations. For two artists who have built reputations on political awareness and activism, what stood out most from Sunday’s performances wasn’t what was said, but rather what was noticeably absent.
That rebellious moment never came from either artist, leaving some fans extremely disappointed. Others wondered if it proved that the Super Bowl, and everything that comes with its corporate-heavy spectacle, is simply too big to challenge.
For music programmers, the performances also provided a firsthand look at the reaction artists that stations play can generate, both positive and negative.
Unfair Expectations?
In today’s ultra-polarized, social-media-hysteric world, many expected both Green Day and Bad Bunny to go full political during their sets. This is why Turning Point USA provided a counterprogrammed halftime show.
However, when both Green Day and Bad Bunny ended their sets, some fans remained unfulfilled.
This year’s Super Bowl took place during a midterm election year and against the backdrop of President Trump. Headlines of ICE enforcement masked the NFL’s continued involvement in culture-war politics. If this wasn’t the perfect opportunity for both artists to speak out, then what was?
From a music media standpoint, it’s interesting to examine whether symbolism alone is enough to satisfy an artist’s vocal fanbase. Or if societal expectations have shifted so dramatically that fans now expect direct confrontation and call-outs.
Past Statements
In the week leading up to the Super Bowl, both Green Day and Bad Bunny had no problem making political statements, something they have done throughout their careers.
“To all the ICE agents out there, wherever you are, quit your sh***y-ass job… because when this is over, and it will be over at some point in time, Kristi Noem, Stephen Miller, JD Vance, Donald Trump, they’re gonna dry like a bad f*****g habit. Come on this side of the line,” Green Day lead singer Billie Joe Armstrong said at the Super Bowl Spotify pre-show party on Saturday night.
During the previous Sunday’s Grammy Awards, Bad Bunny declared, “ICE out!” while accepting his trophy. He empathized that, “We’re not savages. We’re not animals. We’re not aliens. We are humans and we are Americans.”
Despite that history, neither artist mentioned Trump or directly addressed politics during their Super Bowl Sunday performances. For many, the fact that both artists performed at all was symbolic enough of the changing times. The sheer representation of punk rock legends alongside a Latin music superstar felt meaningful on its own.
For others, past behavior and previous statements led them to expect more overt messaging.
Green Day Stuck To The Music
During Green Day’s 2000 hit song American Idiot, Armstrong kept the original lyrics: “You can hear the sound of hysteria / The subliminal mindf**k America?”
He has previously been known to ad-lib and change lyrics to include anti-Trump messaging during recent performances. This time, there were no additional signs of political activism. No lyric changes in other songs or words taped onto guitar amps.
Green Day simply rocked out and kept it about the music.
By comparison, when Rage Against the Machine played Saturday Night Live in 1996, the band famously hung upside-down American flags on their guitar amps. Their second song was cut. They were escorted from the building, and reportedly banned from the show entirely.
And we all know what Sinéad O’Connor did—and what happened to her career afterward.
Expectations vs. Reality
Some Green Day fans expressed frustration, questioning why the band chose restraint during such a prime opportunity. A massive amount of devout fans expressed disappointment for not saying more with a captive worldwide audience.
To be fair, Green Day was likely well aware that NBC’s producers were prepared to censor the performance if the band veered from its expected three-song set.
NBC did mute the curse word “f**k,” which is standard procedure when vulgar language is used.
Bad Bunny Celebrated Culture
Bad Bunny’s reaction was different, largely because his presence alone felt like a victory for many fans. For the overwhelming majority of his audience, he met expectations culturally, if not politically.
Some even praised him for not taking the “bait” that would have pleased right-leaning political commentators. They argued that a more overtly political set would have taken away from what Bad Bunny said the performance was meant to represent.
Inclusion, acceptance, and love for all.
Others still wanted more, believing he should have leveraged the moment more forcefully.
The Super Bowl and Politics
This isn’t about what Green Day or Bad Bunny should or shouldn’t have said. Rather, it’s about expectations once a certain bar has been set. That tension exists for many artists. In particular, those who have historically spoken out on political issues.
Whether it’s “When will Taylor Swift come out and endorse a candidate?” or Kid Rock launching his 2026 Freedom Tour. Expectations often follow past behavior.
The same holds true for music programmers, who have seen firsthand the praise or backlash that comes from playing certain artists. Especially in recent times as audiences grow more vocal.
Ultimately, there’s something to be said for the idea that two politically active global artists performed on the biggest stage in American sports. Moreover the decision to let the music speak for itself. That may signal that the Super Bowl spectacle, for all its cultural reach, is not the place for artists to “do or say more.”
Regardless of what some fans might want.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest information right in your inbox.
