By all accounts, NBC News made a bold move in handing over the reins of NBC Nightly News to Tom Llamas. Replacing Lester Holt — who has long been regarded as one of the most trusted figures in American journalism — is no small task.
In fact, it’s the kind of decision that could have rocked the foundation of a flagship newscast. We’ve seen it happen already this year, as Norah O’Donnell departed CBS Evening News and the ratings continually sank for months on end.
To begin the year, CBS News averaged 5.2 million viewers in the nightly newscast ratings. They slumped to as low as 3.6 million — coincidentally Holt’s final week at NBC Nightly News — and approached that yearly low again during the week of July 21st.
And yet, NBC News should be nothing short of encouraged by what’s happened since the transition: essentially, nothing. No real viewer exodus, no gigantic ratings erosion, and no identity crisis. Tom Llamas hasn’t just filled Lester Holt’s shoes — he’s made the network’s leadership look incredibly smart for trusting him with the job.
To understand why this matters, you have to appreciate the position Holt held. For years, he wasn’t just the face of NBC Nightly News. He was a symbol. He represented the calm, consistency, and credible news anchor that viewers covet.
While network news may not carry the cultural clout it once did, the anchor desk at 30 Rock still holds weight, particularly among viewers looking for a trusted voice to make sense of the day’s chaos. Holt was that voice. When polls came out listing the most trusted names in television news, his name was consistently at the top. So, any change — no matter how carefully orchestrated — came with the risk of alienating a deeply loyal audience.
That’s what makes Llamas’ early tenure so impressive. Not because he’s reinvented the newscast or brought in some flashy new approach, but because the audience hasn’t blinked. He’s steady. He’s polished. He understands the rhythms of network news, and perhaps most importantly, he seems to understand that NBC Nightly News doesn’t need to be reimagined; it just needs to be respected. The formula still works. Llamas is simply proving that he’s capable of executing it.
Transitions like this rarely happen without some form of disruption. Audiences are creatures of habit. They grow accustomed to certain voices, certain styles, and certain cadences. Comfort is as important as content in these spaces. It’s easy to lose that with even the most subtle shift in tone. But what NBC News has done is manage this handoff in a way that doesn’t feel jarring. Llamas slides in with a natural presence. He doesn’t mimic Holt, nor does he attempt to drastically differentiate himself. He delivers the news—clearly, confidently, and credibly. And right now, that’s enough.
There’s a broader lesson here for network executives, too. Often, the instinct is to overcorrect when a legacy figure departs. Networks get anxious. They look to inject youth, style, or some form of disruptive energy into their programming, fearing that continuity equals stagnation. NBC News didn’t go down that road. It didn’t even make much of a spectacle out of the transition. It made a smart, measured choice — and then it let Llamas do his job. That patience is paying off.
Some might argue that it’s too early to claim success. I can understand that point of view, truthfully. But the very absence of chaos speaks volumes. In today’s media environment, where every anchor change is scrutinized and second-guessed, silence is often the best indicator of success. The fact that NBC Nightly News is still holding firm in its role as a dependable evening newscast — albeit in second place behind ABC World News Tonight with David Muir — suggests that viewers have accepted, and perhaps even embraced, Llamas in the role.
Logically, if there were going to be turmoil and ratings issues, they’d happen immediately after the transition and not months or even years later, correct?
It also helps that Llamas isn’t a stranger to the audience. His work on weekends and as a correspondent has given him a leg up in the familiarity department. That familiarity, paired with the newsroom’s consistent tone and presentation, has made for a transition that feels more like evolution than disruption.
Of course, this is still Lester Holt’s legacy in many ways. The credibility he built didn’t vanish when he stepped aside. It lingers in the DNA of the newscast. But that’s also what makes Llamas’ early success notable. He hasn’t just benefited from the structure Holt helped build, he’s shown he can sustain it.
NBC News now finds itself in an enviable position. It has proven that it can hand off its most iconic brand that prominently featured its best news asset without the kind of fallout that’s plagued other networks during similar transitions. It has a host in Tom Llamas who appears committed to the core values of the broadcast, rather than chasing viral moments or theatrical delivery. And it has an audience that, if not openly applauding the change, at the very least hasn’t rejected it.
For a network navigating a rapidly changing media landscape, that’s a win. In fact, it’s more than a win—it’s a validation of institutional trust. Because if viewers were really tuning in just for Lester Holt, they would have left. They didn’t. They’re still there. And that means they were tuning in for NBC Nightly News—for the brand, the reporting, and the standards that define it.
Tom Llamas is proving he can be the next steward of that tradition. And that’s something NBC News should feel extremely good about.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. To stay updated, sign up for our newsletters and get the latest information delivered straight to your inbox.
Garrett Searight is Barrett Media’s News Editor, which includes writing daily news stories, features, and opinion columns. He joined Barrett Media in 2022 after a decade leading several radio brands in several formats, as well as a 5-year stint working in local television. In addition to his work with Barrett Media, he is a radio and TV play-by-play broadcaster. Reach out to him at Garrett@BarrettMedia.com.
